Tap list as of 07/17/2015 is:

Toxic Blonde: Blonde 5.6% ABV. This beer is light and crisp, with a slight raspberry flavor, mild hop and malt character, and light body.

Practice Yoga: Session IPA 5.1% ABV. Named after our friends down this street, this IPA is lacking in alcohol but not flavor, with a lovely hop finish and mild body.

Hanger 18: Porter 6.2% ABV. Our porter is black in color, with plenty of roasty flavor , almost no hop character, and a nice quaffable body.

ISO Heaven: IPA 7.2% ABV. Balanced and drinkable, this golden colored IPA is generously hopped with citra and simcoe hops to give a lovely tropical fruit finish with medium bitterness.

Cap City Hustler: Double IPA 9.1% ABV. The big brother to ISO Heaven, Columbus hops make their presence known in the aroma and taste of this beer, with a dank nose and citrusy finish.

Derailed on 5th: Black IPA 7.6% ABV. Don’t judge a beer by its appearances, this dark hued beer has a medium malt character to it, but is dry hopped to give it a lovely bitter and floral finish.

Porn or Pawn: Pepper Pale Ale 6.2% ABV. Poplano and habenero peppers are used in the brewing process of this beer to create a nice level of heat in this beer which is balanced by a slight amount of hop flavor.

Black Tonic: Stout 8.9% ABV. Dark and with a nice full body, this beer has chocolately notes to it and a nice full body to create a drinkable and delicious brew.

Abby Brunette: Belgian Dubbel 8.2%. A slight residual sweetness and estery banana notes from the Belgian yeast come together nicely in this amber colored beer.

Abby’s Cure: Belgian Tripel 9.6% ABV. This mild and drinkable beer is perfect for the warm weather, with a nice clean finish capped by ester notes generated by the yeast.

Gem City Ruby: Amber 6.9% ABV. Our take on an amber ale, this caramel colored beer has a slight hoppiness, clean finish, and well balanced malt flavors.

Safety 3rd: Triple IPA 11.4% ABV. Safety is never first when drinking this beer. This beer has piney hop notes from the aggressive hopping of this brew.

Night Ender: Imperial Stout 11.9% ABV. The big beer is full of chocolate and coffee flavors with a velvety body and a warming finish.

Danger Zone: Wheatwine 10.2% ABV. This complex beer has some residual malt sweetness which gives way to bitter and tropical notes from the hops.

Imperial Box Troll: Imperial Brown Ale 9.5% ABV. A sweetness reminiscent of caramel and molasses reside in the brew, with almost no hop flavors and a medium body.

Abby XXXX: Belgian Quad 11.3% ABV. The big brother of Belgian beers, this brew is full of malt sweetness, with dark fruit flavors joining in at the finish.

Hot Mess Express: Belgian Strong 11.3% ABV. Esters dominate the nose of this amber beer, with a mild sweetness and traditional Belgian yeast flavors.

This tap list changes regularly, we apologize if the beer you desire is not currently available.

Upcoming Brews
Abby Blonde Cask on Raspberries


Below is a list of all of our Toxic Brews.

  • 5th St. Wheat (Hefeweizen) 6.5 ABV 31 IBU

Fruity esters from Belgian yeast and wheat dominate the flavor. A Toxic twist on a classic Hefeweizen style

  • Abby Blonde (Belgian Blonde) 5.8% ABV 28 IBU

A light easy drinking, belgian ale

  • Abby Brunette (Belgian Dubbel) 8.5% ABV 28 IBU

Brown Belgian with classic nutty and caramel overtones with hints of yeast esters and phenols combine for a complex flavor, inspired by the Abbey monks, named after the brewmaster’s wife, Abby

  • Abby XXXX (Belgian Quad) 11.3% ABV 51 IBU

Deep brown color, heavy malt flavors suggesting raisin and caramel, fruit and spice notes with a warming alcohol finish.

  • Abby’s Cure (Belgian Tripel) 9.5% ABV 34 IBU

The Toxic take on the Belgian Tripel. Lighter in color, higher in alcohol, flavor dominated by select yeast strain and select spices

  • Beta Brown (Belgian Brown) 6.5% ABV – 45 IBU

This is the first beer we brewed on our 7 barrel system. Initially this was intended to be a yeast starter batch, but it turned out to be a very easy drinking brown ale.

  • Black Tonic (Imperial Stout) 9% ABV 65 IBU

A dark, thick imperial stout, with subtle hints of chocolate and coffee flavors from the grains.

  • Black Tonic with Coffee and Vanilla (Imperial Stout) 9% ABV 65 IBU

A dark, thick imperial stout, with subtle hints of chocolate and coffee flavors from the grains.

  • Butternut Apple (Seasonal) 6.9% ABV 38 IBU

A fall and winter seasonal brew made with butternut squash, apples, and spices.

  • Derailed (Black IPA) 7.6% ABV 82 IBU

A Toxic take on the Black IPA. Plenty of hops with a touch of black malts and Belgian yeast.

  • Gem City Ruby (Amber) 6% ABV 24 IBU

An amber ale with a Belgian nose, a subtle hop profile,  and a touch of clove on the finish.

  • Imperial Ruby (Imperial Red) 8.7% ABV 81 IBU

The Toxic Imperial Amber. A malty amber ale with a subtle spicy hop profile and a smooth finish.

  • ISO-Heaven (IPA) 8% ABV 96 IBU

Named after the ISO-Alpha acids that the hops impart after the boil, a staple style for many craft beer lovers

  • ISO-Hell (IPA) 8.8% ABV 96 IBU

An IPA with loads of grapefruit flavors and less sweetness than the ISO-Heaven

  • J.O.T.S. (Imperial IPA ) 9.7% 100+ IBU

Johnny On The Spot Imperial IPA was named after a funny situation which occurred while brewing this beer thanks to our good friend Bryan. This is our version of a west coast style IPA…heavily hopped

  • Kaiserlick (German IPA) 7.6% ABV 88 IBU

The use of German pale ale malts and German hops is the perfect balance for this IPA.

  • Porn or Pawn Pale Ale (Pale Ale) 5.5 ABV 37 IBU

Our Pale Ale. Rumor has it patrons on the balcony of our neighbor’s establishment across the street used to play a game, guessing whether pedestrians were going to the Annex (porn store) or 5th Street Pawn (previous business to occupy our building)

  • Porn or Pawn Pepper Pepper Pale Ale (Pale Ale) 5.5% ABV 37 IBU

Our pale ale with fire roasted poblano and habenaro peppers added.

  • Practice Yoga (IPA) 5.6% ABV 69 IBU

Inspired by our friends and neighbors at Practice Yoga. A session-able IPA, with a well balanced hop profile and a clean dry finish.

  • Refresh (Pale Ale) 6.2% 42 IBU

Great for a hot summer day. Light on the color and body, with a medium hop profile, subtle malt flavor with a hint of apple.

  • Three Two Throwback (Porter) 3.2% ABV 38 IBU

Light bodied, with a roasted malt finish. Lower alcohol, still big on flavor.

These beers are generally all available in 4/8/16 oz sizes. We also feature 32 and 64 oz growlers to go.

Updated 07-17-2015